Leg one banner
Chapter 3

From Fingers to Frames

Grouping Numbers

Seeing smaller groups of objects within larger groups helps us determine the total number of objects more efficiently than counting each object one by one. Sometimes our brains “see” smaller groups inside of larger groups like in the group of nine dots below.  

9 dots with 3 red down the middle
Nine has 3 groups of 3. 
9 dots with 5 red on the right side
Nine has 1 group of 5 plus 4 more. 

Two Hands and Ten Fingers

Early in our mathematical journey, we learn that small numbers can be combined to make larger numbers, and that large numbers can be broken up into combinations of smaller numbers.  To help us learn to compose and decompose numbers, we can access a common math tool, our hands!  With our fingers we can show quantities up to 10.

With 10 fingers on 2 hands, we can count to 10 using one-to-one correspondence, or we can identify numbers up to 10 using different finger combinations. For instance, we “see” that 8 can be a group of5 and 3 or4 and 4.

hands showing 5 and 3
hands showing 4 and 4

Anthropologists believe that humans settled on the base ten number system, in large part, because of our 10 fingers.

This begs the question, would we have a different number system if we had 12 fingers? 

Girl counting with fingers

No! It’s not uncommon to hear adults telling children to stop using their fingers to count. But fingers are connected to our ability to see numbers, and even adults sometimes use fingers to visualize or express quantity. Researchers have discovered that the part of the brain connected to finger movement lights up when we work with numbers, even if we’re not physically using our hands. In fact, the degree to which this part of our brain activates can be a predictor of math achievement, particularly in calculation. Read Jo Boaler and Lang Chen’s article about this research in Learn More below.

Number Rack

Number racks, sometimes called rekenreks, are used to represent quantities and combinations in rows of 10 beads, each row containing 5 red and 5 white beads. How might this model relate to our fingers and hands?

number rack
A classroom number rack
Number rack
A wooden abacus
Abacus

These two counting devices look similar, but the value of individual beads on an abacus changes depending on the bead’s location. On a number rack, a bead is worth 1 unit regardless of its position or row. The number rack also uses two colors—red and white—to focus attention on groups of 5. The abacus is an ancient tool and is used around the world still today. To learn more about its modern day use, reference Learn More below.

A number rack starts with all its beads on the right, showing zero on the left. To represent quantity, beads are moved to the left side, or to the "counting area."

Slide beads below to the left, one by one or in groups, to show the number 6.

What are the different quantities of beads that can be combined to make 6?

Number racks commonly have 2 rows, each with 10 beads. By using 2 rows, one can show various ways to combine smaller numbers to compose larger numbers up to 20.

How might this number rack be used to show 16? 

Perhaps you thought of 16 as 10 + 6 or 8 + 8. Is 9 + 7 a valid combination for 16?

number rack with 10 beads on the top row and 6 on the bottom10 + 6 shows 16 using five-wise counting: 5 + 5 + 5 + 1.
Number rack with 8 beads on the top row and 8 on the bottom.8 + 8 shows 16 using pair-wise counting: 8 pairs of beads.
Number rack with 9 beads on the top row and 7 on the bottom.Nine on the top and 7 on the bottom also make 16 total beads.

Number Frames

Frames are another visual tool used to  group objects for counting. Here are three empty frames: a five-, ten-, and double-ten-frame (twenty-frame).

Empty 5-frame, 10-frame, and double 10-frame

Placing counters inside the frames helps us represent quantity with recognized number groups.

5-frame with 3 counters, 10-frame with 7 counters, and double 10-frame with 15 counters
3 yellow counters; 4 + 3, or 7 blue counters; 10 + 4, or 14 red counters 

Frames support the ability to subitize, or determine quantity at a glance. See how many quantities you can identify in the following frames. Press “Show” to start. Be ready because each frame appears for only a second. 

The previous chapter discussed why zero is not easily represented with dots. 

Nothing at all
Does the empty rectangle provide enough information to show zero?

Without context, the rectangle is only a rectangle—not the best representation for a set of zero objects.

Hands, number racks, and number frames provide helpful contexts to represent zero. They each convey empty sets with no quantity.

0 fingers
0 fingers
0 beads
0 beads
0 counters
0 counters

Grouping numbers into smaller, identifiable numbers of visual objects—our fingers, number rack beads, or counters in number frames—helps us determine quantity more efficiently than counting one by one. Visually identifying small sets of numbers within larger numbers is called conceptual subitizing. Recognizing groups of 5 and 10 is a key skill that will help us in our mathematical journey. It sets the stage for representing and identifying larger numbers.

Learn More

Seeing as Understanding: The Importance of Visual Mathematics for our Brain and Learning

Jo Boaler and others from YouCubed explore the brain research behind the power of visual models for learning math in a Journal of Applied & Computational Mathematics article.

Why Kids Should Use Their Fingers in Math Class

Read more about the power of using our fingers for math in an article by Jo Boaler and Lang Chen in The Atlantic.

The Right Answer? 8,186,699,633,530,061 (An Abacus Makes It Look Almost Easy)

This New York Times article describes the still widespread use of the abacus in Japan.

Interactive Models

Explore and share the visual models used in this chapter: Hands, Hands V2Number Rack, and Number Frames